NPDES WV1031171 · Clean Water Act
SURFACE MINE 1, Gilbert, WV: NPDES WV1031171 discharge permit, effluent exceedances, inspections, penalties
SURFACE MINE 1, Gilbert, West Virginia: Individual permit WV1031171, held by BEN'S CREEK OPERATIONS WV LLC; Effective; issued September 7, 2022, term to September 5, 2027; discharges to ALUM CK.
- Aluminum, total [as Al]: 51 limits, 62 violations of any kind, 11 effluent exceedances, latest April 30, 2025, largest 824% over the limit.
- Iron, total [as Fe]: 49 limits, 54 violations of any kind, 5 effluent exceedances, latest February 28, 2025, largest 526% over the limit.
- Solids, total suspended: 42 limits, 47 violations of any kind, 5 effluent exceedances, latest September 30, 2024, largest 1,577% over the limit.
- Selenium, total recoverable: 51 limits, 54 violations of any kind, 3 effluent exceedances, latest September 30, 2024, largest 87% over the limit.
- Solids, settleable: 20 limits, 144 violations of any kind.
- Manganese, total [as Mn]: 51 limits, 51 violations of any kind.
- Aluminum, dissolved [as Al]: 51 limits, 51 violations of any kind.
- Specific conductance: 48 limits, 48 violations of any kind.
- Sulfate, total [as SO4]: 48 limits, 48 violations of any kind.
- Solids, total dissolved: 48 limits, 48 violations of any kind.
- Toxicity [chronic], Ceriodaphnia dubia: 9 limits, 42 violations of any kind.
- pH: 34 limits, 34 violations of any kind.
- Flow rate: 28 limits, 28 violations of any kind.
- Alkalinity, total [as CaCO3]: 9 limits, 9 violations of any kind.
- Calcium, total [as Ca]: 9 limits, 9 violations of any kind.
- Magnesium, total [as Mg]: 9 limits, 9 violations of any kind.
- Sodium, total [as Na]: 9 limits, 9 violations of any kind.
- Potassium, total [as K]: 9 limits, 9 violations of any kind.
- Stream flow, instantaneous: 6 limits, 6 violations of any kind.
- September 25, 2026: Reconnaissance with Sampling (S).
- June 24, 2026: Sampling (S).
- March 24, 2026: Reconnaissance without Sampling (S).
Other permits held by BEN'S CREEK OPERATIONS WV LLC
- SURFACE #1 & DEEP MINES UPPER CEDAR GROVE #5 & ALMA NO. 2, Charleston: WV0095869, issued 2016-12-14
- HERNSHAW CUT THROUGH, Wharncliffe: WV1007912, issued 2018-09-07
- RIGHTHAND FORK NO. 1, Matewan: WV1013106, issued 2018-01-03
- GLEN ALUM REFUSE AREA, Wharncliffe: WV1013173, issued 2018-09-11
- PATTON NO. 2 DEEP MINE, Charleston: WV1013211, issued 2018-09-07
- RIGHTHAND FORK DEEP MINE, Wharncliffe: WV1016784, issued 2018-09-11
- PATTON NO. 10, Wharncliffe: WV1019058, issued 2018-07-06
- LOWER ALMA DEEP MINE NO.6, Charleston: WV1029801, issued 2018-08-17
- TALLEY HOLLOW SURFACE MINE, Wharncliffe: WV1031295, issued 2024-04-08
SURFACE MINE 1 among its neighbors
7 discharge permits are in the Ben Creek subwatershed (HUC 050702010302); WV1031171 is one. Its county: 147, 1 major; WV1031171 is minor permit.
Other permits in the Ben Creek subwatershed (HUC 050702010302)
- LOW GAP SURFACE MINE, Wharncliffe: WV1016288, minor, term to 2019-02-21
- MATERIAL HANDLING FACILITY, Wharncliffe: WV1011057, minor, term to 2023-10-16
- MTNVIEW TO GILBERT (U330-52-39.70_05), Gilbert: WVR110714, minor, term to 2025-05-30
- POUNDING MILL & BEAR HOLLOW WATER MONITORING, Wharncliffe: WV0117587, minor, term to 2025-05-05
- SURFACE #1 & DEEP MINES UPPER CEDAR GROVE #5 & ALMA NO. 2, Charleston: WV0095869, minor, term to 2021-12-12
- TWISTED GUN GAP HAULROAD, Oak Hill: WV1024965, minor, term to 2022-04-03
What stands out
- Its term runs 4 years and 363 days, September 7, 2022 to September 5, 2027.
- Its newest dated event on file is an inspection on September 25, 2026.
- In the 365 days to September 15, 2026, it was dated 2 inspections.
- EPA's file dates 3 events for it, all in 2026.
- 4 of its 19 pollutants on file have an effluent exceedance (21%); 19 are under a numeric limit; the largest exceedance is Solids, total suspended at 1,577% over its limit.
- It is one of 3,734 discharge permits on the register in West Virginia; the file names no program for it, and it is a minor discharger.
Identity
| Facility | SURFACE MINE 1 |
|---|---|
| Permittee | BEN'S CREEK OPERATIONS WV LLC |
| NPDES ID | WV1031171 |
| Status | Effective |
| Type | Individual permit |
| Class | Minor |
| Facility type | Non-POTW |
| Issued | September 7, 2022 |
| Expires | September 5, 2027 |
| Address | Gilbert, WV 25621 |
| Receiving water | ALUM CK |
| Receiving water impaired | 303(D) Listed |
| Subwatershed | Ben Creek (HUC 050702010302) |
NPDES WV1031171: effluent limits and exceedances
SURFACE MINE 1 (NPDES WV1031171): 19 pollutants on file, 19 limited; 19 with a violation of any kind, 4 with an exceedance.
| Pollutant | Limits | Violations | Exceedances | Latest | Largest, as filed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aluminum, total [as Al] | 51 | 62 | 11 | April 30, 2025 | 824% over the limit |
| Iron, total [as Fe] | 49 | 54 | 5 | February 28, 2025 | 526% over the limit |
| Solids, total suspended | 42 | 47 | 5 | September 30, 2024 | 1,577% over the limit |
| Selenium, total recoverable | 51 | 54 | 3 | September 30, 2024 | 87% over the limit |
| Solids, settleable | 20 | 144 | 0 | ||
| Manganese, total [as Mn] | 51 | 51 | 0 | ||
| Aluminum, dissolved [as Al] | 51 | 51 | 0 | ||
| Specific conductance | 48 | 48 | 0 | ||
| Sulfate, total [as SO4] | 48 | 48 | 0 | ||
| Solids, total dissolved | 48 | 48 | 0 | ||
| Toxicity [chronic], Ceriodaphnia dubia | 9 | 42 | 0 | ||
| pH | 34 | 34 | 0 | ||
| Flow rate | 28 | 28 | 0 | ||
| Alkalinity, total [as CaCO3] | 9 | 9 | 0 | ||
| Calcium, total [as Ca] | 9 | 9 | 0 | ||
| Magnesium, total [as Mg] | 9 | 9 | 0 | ||
| Sodium, total [as Na] | 9 | 9 | 0 | ||
| Potassium, total [as K] | 9 | 9 | 0 | ||
| Stream flow, instantaneous | 6 | 6 | 0 |
NPDES WV1031171: inspections, violations and enforcement
NPDES WV1031171: 3 inspections
| Date | What EPA recorded | Agency |
|---|---|---|
| September 25, 2026 | Reconnaissance with Sampling | S |
| June 24, 2026 | Sampling | S |
| March 24, 2026 | Reconnaissance without Sampling | S |
NPDES WV1031171 (SURFACE MINE 1): no single-event violation, formal enforcement action and informal enforcement action on file.
Watch NPDES WV1031171
NPDES WV1031171: one email when its EPA record changes — $99/month.
Permits near NPDES WV1031171
NPDES WV1031171: 19 pollutant rows, 3 dated events; ICIS-NPDES download, loaded September 15, 2026.