Skilled nursing facility · CMS certification number 335668
Kirkhaven
Rochester, New York · Medicare and Medicaid · 147 certified beds in Care Compare
Download Kirkhaven’s record (CSV, each figure with its worksheet, line and column)
In Care Compare’s provider information: Penalties: 1 · Fines: 1 · Fines, total amount: $8,278.00 · Payment denials: 0. The most recent penalty on file: December 8, 2025, Fine, $8,278. Every penalty on file ↓
Kirkhaven: its citable report, full history — $295 · an email when it changes — $99/month
What stands out
- Its latest cost report on file is for fiscal year 2024, covering January 1, 2024 to December 31, 2024 (365 days), and CMS processed it on August 28, 2025.
- Net patient revenue rose from $13.7M in fiscal year 2023 to $15.5M in fiscal year 2024.
- Its result from service to patients: −$4.6M (2022), −$1.2M (2023), −$1.1M (2024).
- Its cost reports on file run from fiscal year 1996 to fiscal year 2024.
- Its net patient revenue of $15.5M ranks 358th of the 539 nursing facilities in New York whose latest cost report on file is fiscal year 2024.
- 4 of the 5 nursing facilities in New York closest in size to it, whose latest cost report on file is fiscal year 2024, also report a loss on service to patients.
Kirkhaven: Medicare cost reports
Form CMS-2540-10: each report covers January 1 to December 31 of its year; every report is settled.
| Form CMS-2540-10 | 2024 · report 1434875 | 2023 · report 1391370 | 2022 · report 1349020 | 2021 · report 1327712 | 2020 · report 1303559 | 2019 · report 1274877 | 2018 · report 1241418 | 2017 · report 1210083 | 2016 · report 1174599 | 2015 · report 1136697 | 2014 · report 1122733 | 2013 · report 1076665 | 2012 · report 1044490 | 2011 · report 1011159 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Processed by CMS | August 28, 2025 | August 7, 2024 | May 31, 2023 | July 22, 2022 | November 10, 2021 | December 3, 2020 | August 20, 2019 | August 22, 2018 | August 23, 2017 | July 25, 2016 | April 27, 2016 | August 22, 2014 | August 1, 2013 | September 21, 2012 |
| Total patient revenue | $25,973,689 | $22,441,637 | $18,521,809 | $18,515,317 | $21,071,618 | $22,313,371 | $21,623,184 | $12,765,304 | — | $13,048,682 | $11,795,793 | $11,595,747 | $11,810,738 | $12,641,176 |
| Contractual allowances and discounts | $10,509,493 | $8,770,027 | $7,541,941 | $8,318,142 | $9,153,137 | $8,304,503 | $7,958,523 | $131,706 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Net patient revenue | $15,464,196 | $13,671,610 | $10,979,868 | $10,197,175 | $11,918,481 | $14,008,868 | $13,664,661 | $12,633,598 | — | $13,048,682 | $11,795,793 | $11,595,747 | $11,810,738 | $12,641,176 |
| Total operating expenses | $16,604,553 | $14,855,295 | $15,558,153 | $13,066,397 | $14,845,004 | $15,120,707 | $14,199,428 | $13,957,235 | — | $12,649,493 | $12,059,210 | $12,526,912 | $12,483,491 | $12,364,584 |
| Net income from service to patients | −$1,140,357 | −$1,183,685 | −$4,578,285 | −$2,869,222 | −$2,926,523 | −$1,111,839 | −$534,767 | −$1,323,637 | — | $399,189 | −$263,417 | −$931,165 | −$672,753 | $276,592 |
| Total other income | $4,893,117 | $2,142,320 | $3,372,896 | $6,930,988 | $3,242,003 | $256,445 | $746,556 | $1,827,523 | — | $210,383 | $362,855 | $2,937,778 | $340,817 | $216,607 |
| Net income after other income | $3,752,760 | $958,635 | −$1,205,389 | $4,061,766 | $315,480 | −$855,394 | $211,789 | $503,886 | — | $609,572 | $99,438 | $2,006,613 | −$331,936 | $493,199 |
| Net income | $3,752,760 | $1,141,732 | −$2,301,780 | $4,061,766 | −$323,387 | −$1,854,476 | −$46,626 | $372,887 | — | $372,635 | −$2,602,628 | $1,527,467 | −$617,064 | −$1,565,163 |
| Total facility beds, all components | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | — | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 |
| Bed days available, all components | 53,802 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Medicare (Title XVIII) patient days | 4,585 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Medicaid (Title XIX) patient days | 23,572 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Other-payer patient days | 20,362 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Total patient days, all components | 48,519 | 44,538 | 39,010 | 39,682 | 45,345 | 51,276 | 52,000 | 49,955 | — | 51,660 | 50,080 | 50,146 | 49,878 | 49,031 |
| Medicare discharges | 101 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Medicaid discharges | 75 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Other-payer discharges | 205 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Total discharges, all components | 381 | 219 | 274 | 226 | 245 | 206 | 146 | 129 | — | 158 | 191 | 171 | 169 | 240 |
| Average length of stay, Medicare, in days | 45.4 | 57.82 | 38.82 | 41.12 | 53.08 | 35.56 | 37.84 | 54.3 | — | 47.97 | 41.32 | 48.1 | 72.11 | 42 |
| Average length of stay, Medicaid, in days | 314.29 | 521.8 | 183.04 | 415.59 | 290.57 | 387.8 | 607.21 | 1,535.44 | — | 976.89 | 884.08 | 1,601.32 | 1,122.35 | 567.32 |
| Average length of stay, all patients, in days | 127.35 | 203.37 | 142.37 | 175.58 | 185.08 | 248.91 | 356.16 | 387.25 | — | 326.96 | 262.2 | 293.25 | 295.14 | 204.3 |
Net income, fiscal years 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011. Checked against the form’s own arithmetic: what that check shows.
None of these figures is carried on the report for fiscal year 2016.
Form CMS-2540-96: each report covers January 1 to December 31 of its year.
| Form CMS-2540-96 | 2010 · report 419085 | 2009 · report 386014 | 2008 · report 356493 | 2007 · report 327274 | 2006 · report 307275 | 2005 · report 261090 | 2004 · report 233947 | 2003 · report 196280 | 2002 · report 165078 | 2001 · report 160550 | 2000 · report 113898 | 1999 · report 38818 | 1998 · report 38816 | 1997 · report 38814 | 1996 · report 38812 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Report status | reopened | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled | settled |
| Processed by CMS | October 21, 2011 | August 23, 2010 | September 10, 2009 | October 27, 2008 | April 23, 2008 | August 14, 2006 | September 30, 2005 | September 29, 2004 | December 11, 2003 | September 24, 2003 | February 11, 2003 | May 2, 2001 | July 20, 2000 | January 11, 1999 | August 12, 1998 |
| Net patient revenue | $11,691,414 | $11,910,584 | $11,771,508 | — | $10,798,690 | $10,282,741 | $10,434,322 | $9,824,967 | $9,594,742 | $9,217,540 | $9,012,776 | $8,765,395 | $8,667,411 | $8,291,231 | $7,932,875 |
| Total operating expenses | $11,972,792 | $12,605,528 | $12,305,949 | $11,173,502 | $10,666,326 | $10,894,711 | $10,251,617 | $10,256,454 | $10,025,140 | $9,364,272 | $9,499,087 | $9,248,328 | $8,722,942 | $7,993,648 | $7,933,658 |
| Net income from service to patients | −$281,378 | −$694,944 | −$534,441 | — | $132,364 | −$611,970 | $182,705 | −$431,487 | −$430,398 | −$146,732 | −$486,311 | −$482,933 | −$55,531 | $297,583 | −$783 |
| Total other income | $175,899 | $113,593 | $233,891 | — | $88,717 | $95,771 | $98,144 | $260,149 | $273,969 | $317,493 | $546,335 | $625,679 | $721,016 | $198,568 | $212,332 |
| Total other expenses | $322,809 | $795,001 | −$1,870,216 | — | −$539,201 | −$59,011 | — | — | $69,981 | $65,899 | $13,015 | — | — | — | — |
| Net income | −$428,288 | −$1,376,352 | $1,569,666 | — | $760,282 | −$457,188 | $280,849 | −$171,338 | −$226,410 | $104,862 | $47,009 | $142,746 | $665,485 | $496,151 | $211,549 |
| Total facility beds, all components | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 | 147 |
| Total patient days, all components | 49,627 | 49,585 | 49,922 | 50,360 | 50,434 | 49,732 | 51,341 | 50,421 | 50,385 | 51,734 | 50,637 | 50,595 | 51,161 | 51,925 | 52,031 |
| Total discharges, all components | 301 | 299 | 327 | 208 | 272 | 241 | 199 | 189 | 170 | 187 | 214 | 173 | 146 | 110 | 121 |
| Average length of stay, Medicare, in days | 52.29 | 41.16 | 41.9 | 492 | 35.54 | 39.03 | 32.1 | 27.31 | 40.75 | 31.37 | 41.04 | 49.24 | 54 | 91.46 | 100.83 |
| Average length of stay, Medicaid, in days | 317.79 | 309.23 | 309.35 | 224.55 | 437.42 | 455.11 | 1,289.87 | 720.98 | 1,040.57 | 432.38 | 700 | 383 | 695.55 | 1,376.32 | 1,001.21 |
| Average length of stay, all patients, in days | 164.87 | 165.84 | 152.67 | 242.12 | 185.42 | 206.36 | 257.99 | 266.78 | 296.38 | 276.65 | 236.62 | 292.46 | 350.42 | 472.05 | 430.01 |
Net income, fiscal years 2010, 2009, 2008, 2006, 2005, 2004, 2003, 2002, 2001, 2000, 1999, 1998, 1997, 1996. Checked against the form’s own arithmetic: what that check shows.
Kirkhaven: nurse staffing hours by quarter →
Who owns Kirkhaven, as filed with CMS
Care Compare
- CORPORATE DIRECTOR: FORNATARO, LETICIA (individual), since 01/01/2019; MUTHIG, MARK (individual), since 01/01/2021
- CORPORATE OFFICER: MAAR, SCOTT (individual), since 05/04/2005; SCHALLER, CHRISTINE (individual), since 12/19/2022
- OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL: SCHALLER, CHRISTINE (individual), since 12/19/2022
Ownership percentage for each: NOT APPLICABLE.
Medicare enrollment
As filed in the CMS file dated October 1, 2026 (Medicare enrollment ownership), under the enrollment of GENESEE VALLEY PRESBYTERIAN NURSING CENTER (enrollment ID O20050421000419).
- CORPORATE DIRECTOR: LETICIA FORNATARO (individual), since 01/01/2019; MARK MUTHIG (individual), since 01/01/2021
- CORPORATE OFFICER: SCOTT MAAR (individual), since 05/04/2005
- OFFICER: CHRISTINE P SCHALLER (individual), since 12/19/2022
- OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL: CHRISTINE P SCHALLER (individual), since 12/19/2022
Ownership percentage for each: not stated in the filing.
Private equity company, real estate investment trust and holding company: “Paused by CMS” for every owner listed here. Paused by CMS: Form CMS-855A, December 11, 2025.
Changes in ownership
- April 14, 2023, enrollment ownership file; no longer listed: LETICIA FORNATARO (OFFICER); JOHN WARD (OFFICER); MARK MUTHIG (OFFICER); ANNE ROOT GALLESE (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL); ANNE ROOT GALLESE (W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE); ANNE ROOT GALLESE (DIRECTOR); SCOTT MAAR (DIRECTOR); first listed: LETICIA FORNATARO (DIRECTOR), associated since January 1, 2019; MARK MUTHIG (DIRECTOR), associated since January 1, 2021; CHRISTINE P SCHALLER (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 19, 2022; CHRISTINE P SCHALLER (OFFICER), associated since December 19, 2022; SCOTT MAAR (OFFICER), associated since May 4, 2005. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2023-04-14.csv
Inspections of Kirkhaven
- Cycle 1: health December 9, 2024 (21 deficiencies), fire safety December 9, 2024 (5)
- Cycle 2: health March 16, 2023 (7 deficiencies), fire safety March 16, 2023 (5)
- Cycle 3: health April 2, 2021 (2 deficiencies), fire safety April 2, 2021 (4)
Deficiencies cited at Kirkhaven
30 deficiencies on file, by tag, newest citation first
every one from a health inspection; every one marked “Deficient, Provider has date of correction”; 13 cited from a complaint, marked below. Letter after a date: scope and severity grade.
- F 0550, resident rights: March 18, 2026 (D, from a complaint, corrected May 15, 2026); December 8, 2025 (G, from a complaint, corrected February 6, 2026).
- F 0610, freedom from abuse, neglect, and exploitation: March 18, 2026 (E, from a complaint, corrected May 15, 2026); March 16, 2023 (D, corrected May 15, 2023).
- F 0677, quality of life and care: March 18, 2026 (E, from a complaint, corrected May 15, 2026); December 8, 2025 (E, from a complaint, corrected February 6, 2026).
- F 0689, quality of life and care: March 18, 2026 (E, from a complaint, corrected May 15, 2026).
- F 0725, nursing and physician services: March 18, 2026 (E, from a complaint, corrected May 15, 2026).
- F 0803, nutrition and dietary: March 18, 2026 (D, from a complaint, corrected May 15, 2026).
- F 0658, resident assessment and care planning: December 8, 2025 (D, from a complaint, corrected February 6, 2026).
- F 0761, pharmacy service: December 8, 2025 (E, from a complaint, corrected February 6, 2026).
- F 0684, quality of life and care: July 16, 2025 (D, from a complaint, corrected September 10, 2025); December 9, 2024 (D, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0578, resident rights: December 9, 2024 (D, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0644, resident assessment and care planning: December 9, 2024 (E, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0656, resident assessment and care planning: December 9, 2024 (D, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0685, quality of life and care: December 9, 2024 (D, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0692, quality of life and care: December 9, 2024 (D, from a complaint, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0695, quality of life and care: December 9, 2024 (E, corrected February 5, 2025); April 2, 2021 (D, corrected June 1, 2021).
- F 0744, quality of life and care: December 9, 2024 (D, from a complaint, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0805, nutrition and dietary: December 9, 2024 (D, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0812, nutrition and dietary: December 9, 2024 (E, corrected February 5, 2025); March 16, 2023 (E, corrected May 15, 2023).
- F 0880, infection control: December 9, 2024 (E, corrected February 5, 2025).
- F 0561, resident rights: March 16, 2023 (D, corrected May 15, 2023).
- F 0600, freedom from abuse, neglect, and exploitation: March 16, 2023 (D, corrected May 15, 2023).
- F 0698, quality of life and care: March 16, 2023 (E, corrected May 15, 2023); April 2, 2021 (D, corrected June 1, 2021).
- F 0760, pharmacy service: March 16, 2023 (D, corrected May 15, 2023).
Penalties
| Penalty date | Type | Fine amount | Payment denial began | Payment denial, days | Fine ID |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| December 8, 2025 | Fine | $8,278 | 138526 |
From the Care Compare penalties file NH_Penalties_Oct2026.csv, processed on October 1, 2026.
Kirkhaven in Care Compare
- Ownership Type: Non profit - Corporation
- Legal Business Name: GENESEE VALLEY PRESBYTERIAN NURSING CENTER
- Date First Approved to Provide Medicare and Medicaid Services: 1984-02-20
- Provider Resides in Hospital: N
- Continuing Care Retirement Community: N
- Urban: Y
- County/Parish: Monroe
- Telephone Number: 5854611991
- Provider Changed Ownership in Last 12 Months: N
- With a Resident and Family Council: Resident
- Automatic Sprinkler Systems in All Required Areas: Yes
- Average Number of Residents per Day: 130.0
- Overall Rating: 1
- Health Inspection Rating: 1
- QM Rating: 3
- Long-Stay QM Rating: 3
- Short-Stay QM Rating: 3
Care Compare, October 1, 2026: provider information NH_ProviderInfo_Oct2026.csv · inspections NH_SurveySummary_Oct2026.csv · citations NH_HealthCitations_Oct2026.csv · penalties NH_Penalties_Oct2026.csv · ownership NH_Ownership_Oct2026.csv.
Other nursing facilities in Rochester
Report a figure on Kirkhaven’s record that differs from its CMS file, quoting 335668.