Skilled nursing facility · CMS certification number 366376
OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN
FRANKLIN, Ohio · Medicare and Medicaid · 60 certified beds in Care Compare
Download OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN’s record (CSV, each figure with its worksheet, line and column)
OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN: its citable report, full history — $295 · an email when it changes — $99/month
What stands out
- Its latest cost report on file is for fiscal year 2024, covering January 1, 2024 to December 31, 2024 (365 days), and CMS processed it on August 28, 2025.
- Net patient revenue rose from $7,490,879 in fiscal year 2023 to $7,530,208 in fiscal year 2024.
- Its result from service to patients: −$844K (2022), $602K (2023), $227K (2024).
- Its cost reports on file run from fiscal year 2009 to fiscal year 2024.
- Its net patient revenue of $7.5M ranks 507th of the 830 nursing facilities in Ohio whose latest cost report on file is fiscal year 2024.
- 3 of the 5 nursing facilities in Ohio closest in size to it, whose latest cost report on file is fiscal year 2024, also report a gain on service to patients.
OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN: Medicare cost reports
Form CMS-2540-10: each report covers January 1 to December 31 of its year; every report is settled.
| Form CMS-2540-10 | 2024 · report 1435182 | 2023 · report 1390118 | 2022 · report 1360102 | 2021 · report 1330444 | 2020 · report 1304293 | 2019 · report 1264465 | 2018 · report 1235758 | 2017 · report 1200046 | 2016 · report 1169376 | 2015 · report 1137594 | 2014 · report 1144206 | 2013 · report 1113027 | 2012 · report 1072581 | 2011 · report 1044373 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Processed by CMS | August 28, 2025 | July 23, 2024 | July 27, 2023 | August 23, 2022 | November 11, 2021 | August 20, 2020 | July 10, 2019 | July 19, 2018 | July 17, 2017 | July 25, 2016 | September 30, 2016 | November 19, 2015 | July 23, 2014 | July 30, 2013 |
| Total patient revenue | $11,352,647 | $11,057,734 | $10,434,338 | $8,229,100 | $8,093,498 | $8,896,591 | $8,646,380 | $8,363,205 | $8,172,681 | $7,967,000 | $7,879,486 | $7,707,202 | $7,781,302 | $7,158,200 |
| Contractual allowances and discounts | $3,822,439 | $3,566,855 | $3,914,177 | $2,941,296 | $2,882,297 | $3,311,097 | $3,162,994 | $3,002,917 | $2,873,152 | $2,799,915 | $2,871,685 | $2,704,767 | $2,793,147 | $1,867,912 |
| Net patient revenue | $7,530,208 | $7,490,879 | $6,520,161 | $5,287,804 | $5,211,201 | $5,585,494 | $5,483,386 | $5,360,288 | $5,299,529 | $5,167,085 | $5,007,801 | $5,002,435 | $4,988,155 | $5,290,288 |
| Total operating expenses | $7,302,918 | $6,888,552 | $7,363,669 | $5,457,062 | $5,408,857 | $5,308,799 | $5,397,753 | $5,073,833 | $5,053,805 | $4,927,553 | $4,701,687 | $4,732,437 | $4,752,895 | $4,800,911 |
| Net income from service to patients | $227,290 | $602,327 | −$843,508 | −$169,258 | −$197,656 | $276,695 | $85,633 | $286,455 | $245,724 | $239,532 | $306,114 | $269,998 | $235,260 | $489,377 |
| Total other income | $702 | $344 | $198,717 | $284,007 | $201,367 | $2,119 | $37,840 | $9,668 | $5,928 | $10,331 | $5,685 | $4,011 | $7,213 | $4,094 |
| Net income after other income | $227,992 | $602,671 | −$644,791 | $114,749 | $3,711 | $278,814 | $123,473 | $296,123 | $251,652 | $249,863 | $311,799 | $274,009 | $242,473 | $493,471 |
| Net income | $227,992 | $602,671 | −$644,791 | $114,749 | $3,711 | $278,814 | $123,473 | $296,123 | $251,652 | $249,863 | $311,799 | $274,009 | $242,473 | $493,471 |
| Total facility beds, all components | 60 | 60 | 60 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 |
| Bed days available, all components | 21,960 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Medicare (Title XVIII) patient days | 2,339 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Medicaid (Title XIX) patient days | 3,537 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Other-payer patient days | 14,172 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Total patient days, all components | 20,048 | 20,385 | 19,023 | 15,528 | 15,430 | 17,181 | 16,588 | 16,458 | 16,762 | 16,889 | 16,816 | 16,825 | 17,247 | 16,049 |
| Medicare discharges | 102 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Medicaid discharges | 46 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Other-payer discharges | 277 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Total discharges, all components | 425 | 374 | 421 | 377 | 274 | 270 | 315 | 247 | 251 | 231 | 216 | 187 | 203 | 232 |
| Average length of stay, Medicare, in days | 22.93 | 23.03 | 29.28 | 23.62 | 28.82 | 28.67 | 23.2 | 26.5 | 25.49 | 26.95 | 27.88 | 35.86 | 25.2 | 28.5 |
| Average length of stay, Medicaid, in days | 76.89 | 184 | 28.36 | 34.22 | 43.67 | 63.66 | 63.59 | 86.65 | 127.37 | 111.7 | 252.31 | 339.5 | 389.04 | 356.08 |
| Average length of stay, all patients, in days | 47.17 | 54.51 | 45.19 | 41.19 | 56.31 | 63.63 | 52.66 | 66.63 | 66.78 | 73.11 | 77.85 | 89.97 | 84.96 | 69.18 |
Net income, fiscal years 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011. Checked against the form’s own arithmetic: what that check shows.
Form CMS-2540-96: every report is settled.
| Form CMS-2540-96 | 2010 · report 432469 | 2009 · report 399962 |
|---|---|---|
| Period began | January 1, 2010 | June 8, 2009 |
| Period ended | December 31, 2010 | December 31, 2009 |
| Days, where not a full year | — | 206 |
| Processed by CMS | September 24, 2012 | May 19, 2011 |
| Net patient revenue | $5,047,817 | $2,205,688 |
| Total operating expenses | $4,624,090 | $2,517,685 |
| Net income from service to patients | $423,727 | −$311,997 |
| Total other income | $6,400 | $5,815 |
| Total other expenses | −$1,269 | $1,106 |
| Net income | $431,396 | −$307,288 |
| Total facility beds, all components | 50 | 50 |
| Total patient days, all components | 14,463 | 6,210 |
| Total discharges, all components | 280 | 111 |
| Average length of stay, Medicare, in days | 28.32 | 40.25 |
| Average length of stay, Medicaid, in days | 197.15 | 83.47 |
| Average length of stay, all patients, in days | 51.65 | 55.95 |
Net income, fiscal years 2010, 2009. Checked against the form’s own arithmetic: what that check shows.
OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN: nurse staffing hours by quarter →
Who owns OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN, as filed with CMS
Care Compare
- 5% OR GREATER DIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST: OTTERBEIN NEIGHBORHOODS, LLC (organization), 100%%, since 01/01/2016
- 5% OR GREATER INDIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST: OTTERBEIN HOME (organization), 100%%, since 12/01/2021
- ADP OF THE SNF: DIXON, KOBY (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 06/11/2025; FUNCTIONAL PATHWAYS OF TENNESSEE LLC (organization), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/04/2025; NOLAN-LAWLER, KATHLEEN (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 06/05/2017; OTTERBEIN HOME (organization), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; POLARIS PHARMACY SERVICES OF OHIO LLC (organization), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2018
- CORPORATE OFFICER: GREEN, JAMES (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 11/21/2005; WILSON, JILL (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 05/01/2009
- INDIVIDUAL IS AN OWNER, PARTNER OR TRUSTEE OF ANY ADP OF THE SNF: BAKER, STEVE (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/04/2025; GALBUT, ABRAHAM (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/04/2025; GALBUT, DANIEL (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/06/2025; GALBUT, DAVID (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/04/2025; GALBUT, ERIC (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/06/2025; GALBUT, ROBERT (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/04/2025; PARITZKY, JONATHAN (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/04/2025; ROMBRO, DAVID (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/04/2025; WILSON, JILL (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 08/04/2025; ZISEK, TODD (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 04/04/2025
- OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL: APP, LYNN (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; BARTLETT, VICTORIA (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; BAYLIFF, BECKY (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; BROWNSON, WILLIAM (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; BURKE, DANIEL (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; COLEMAN, ROBERT (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; DIXON, KOBY (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; FRALEY, RALPH (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; FUNCTIONAL PATHWAYS OF TENNESSEE LLC (organization), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2018; GLOSSER, HEIDI (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; GREEN, JAMES (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; HAZELBAKER, TOMAS (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; NOLAN-LAWLER, KATHLEEN (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 06/05/2017; OTTERBEIN HOME (organization), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021; VONDERHAAR, STEVE (individual), NOT APPLICABLE, since 12/01/2021
Medicare enrollment
As filed in the CMS file dated October 1, 2026 (Medicare enrollment ownership), under the enrollment of OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN LLC (enrollment ID O20090107000422).
- 5% OR GREATER DIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST: OTTERBEIN NEIGHBORHOODS, LLC (organization), 100.00%, since 01/01/2016
- 5% OR GREATER INDIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST: OTTERBEIN HOME (organization), 100.00%, since 12/01/2021
- ADP OF THE SNF: FUNCTIONAL PATHWAYS OF TENNESSEE LLC (organization), since 04/04/2025; KATHLEEN NOLAN-LAWLER (individual), since 06/05/2017; KOBY MICHAEL DIXON (individual), since 06/11/2025; OTTERBEIN HOME (organization), since 12/01/2021; POLARIS PHARMACY SERVICES OF OHIO LLC (organization), since 12/01/2018
- CORPORATE OFFICER: JAMES CHRISTOPHER GREEN (individual), since 11/21/2005; JILL WILSON (individual), since 05/01/2009
- OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL: BECKY BAYLIFF (individual), since 12/01/2021; DANIEL BURKE (individual), since 12/01/2021; FUNCTIONAL PATHWAYS OF TENNESSEE LLC (organization), since 12/01/2018; HEIDI GLOSSER (individual), since 12/01/2021; JAMES CHRISTOPHER GREEN (individual), since 12/01/2021; KATHLEEN NOLAN-LAWLER (individual), since 06/05/2017; KOBY MICHAEL DIXON (individual), since 12/01/2021; LYNN APP (individual), since 12/01/2021; OTTERBEIN HOME (organization), since 12/01/2021; RALPH REED FRALEY (individual), since 12/01/2021; ROBERT COLEMAN (individual), since 12/01/2021; STEVE VONDERHAAR (individual), since 12/01/2021; TOMAS HAZELBAKER (individual), since 12/01/2021; VICTORIA BARTLETT (individual), since 12/01/2021; WILLIAM BROWNSON (individual), since 12/01/2021
Paused by CMS: Form CMS-855A, December 11, 2025.
Private equity company, real estate investment trust and holding company: No: OTTERBEIN NEIGHBORHOODS, LLC; OTTERBEIN HOME; FUNCTIONAL PATHWAYS OF TENNESSEE LLC; OTTERBEIN HOME; POLARIS PHARMACY SERVICES OF OHIO LLC; FUNCTIONAL PATHWAYS OF TENNESSEE LLC; OTTERBEIN HOME.
Private equity company, real estate investment trust and holding company: Paused by CMS: KATHLEEN NOLAN-LAWLER; KOBY MICHAEL DIXON; JAMES CHRISTOPHER GREEN; JILL WILSON; BECKY BAYLIFF; DANIEL BURKE; HEIDI GLOSSER; JAMES CHRISTOPHER GREEN; KATHLEEN NOLAN-LAWLER; KOBY MICHAEL DIXON; LYNN APP; RALPH REED FRALEY; ROBERT COLEMAN; STEVE VONDERHAAR; TOMAS HAZELBAKER; VICTORIA BARTLETT; WILLIAM BROWNSON.
Changes in ownership
- October 1, 2025, enrollment ownership file; no longer listed: DONALD GILMORE (W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE); JAMES CHRISTOPHER GREEN (W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE); OTTERBEIN HOLDINGS, LLC (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL); JILL WILSON (W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE); first listed: STEVE VONDERHAAR (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; KOBY MICHAEL DIXON (ADP OF THE SNF), associated since June 11, 2025; KOBY MICHAEL DIXON (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; LYNN APP (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; DANIEL BURKE (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; ROBERT COLEMAN (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; JAMES CHRISTOPHER GREEN (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; JAMES CHRISTOPHER GREEN (CORPORATE OFFICER), associated since November 21, 2005; OTTERBEIN HOME (ADP OF THE SNF), associated since December 1, 2021; OTTERBEIN HOME (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; OTTERBEIN HOME (5% OR GREATER INDIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST), associated since December 1, 2021; JILL WILSON (CORPORATE OFFICER), associated since May 1, 2009; OTTERBEIN NEIGHBORHOODS, LLC (5% OR GREATER DIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST), associated since January 1, 2016; FUNCTIONAL PATHWAYS OF TENNESSEE LLC (ADP OF THE SNF), associated since April 4, 2025; FUNCTIONAL PATHWAYS OF TENNESSEE LLC (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2018; RALPH REED FRALEY (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; TOMAS HAZELBAKER (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; WILLIAM BROWNSON (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; VICTORIA BARTLETT (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; KATHLEEN NOLAN-LAWLER (ADP OF THE SNF), associated since June 5, 2017; KATHLEEN NOLAN-LAWLER (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since June 5, 2017; HEIDI GLOSSER (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021; POLARIS PHARMACY SERVICES OF OHIO LLC (ADP OF THE SNF), associated since December 1, 2018; BECKY BAYLIFF (OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL), associated since December 1, 2021. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2025-10-01.csv
Inspections of OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN
- Cycle 1: health January 8, 2026 (9 deficiencies), fire safety January 8, 2026 (4)
- Cycle 2: health August 15, 2022 (9 deficiencies), fire safety August 15, 2022 (8)
- Cycle 3: health August 29, 2019 (1 deficiencies), fire safety August 29, 2019 (4)
Deficiencies cited at OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN
19 deficiencies on file, by tag, newest citation first
every one from a health inspection; 1 cited from a complaint, marked below. Letter after a date: scope and severity grade.
- F 0578, resident rights: January 8, 2026 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected February 9, 2026).
- F 0584, resident rights: January 8, 2026 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected February 9, 2026).
- F 0636, resident assessment and care planning: January 8, 2026 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected February 9, 2026).
- F 0687, quality of life and care: January 8, 2026 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected February 9, 2026).
- F 0689, quality of life and care: January 8, 2026 (E, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected February 9, 2026); October 14, 2025 (D, from a complaint, Past Non-Compliance, corrected October 6, 2025); August 15, 2022 (E, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0812, nutrition and dietary: January 8, 2026 (E, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected February 9, 2026); August 15, 2022 (E, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0842, resident assessment and care planning: January 8, 2026 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected February 9, 2026).
- F 0880, infection control: January 8, 2026 (E, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected February 9, 2026); August 15, 2022 (E, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0679, quality of life and care: August 15, 2022 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0685, quality of life and care: August 15, 2022 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0690, quality of life and care: August 15, 2022 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0695, quality of life and care: August 15, 2022 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0770, administration: August 15, 2022 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0791, quality of life and care: August 15, 2022 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected November 18, 2022).
- F 0644, resident assessment and care planning: August 29, 2019 (D, Deficient, Provider has date of correction, corrected September 16, 2019).
OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN in Care Compare
- Ownership Type: Non profit - Church related
- Legal Business Name: OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN LLC
- Date First Approved to Provide Medicare and Medicaid Services: 2009-06-08
- Provider Resides in Hospital: N
- Continuing Care Retirement Community: N
- Urban: Y
- County/Parish: Warren
- Telephone Number: 5137274590
- Chain Name: OTTERBEIN SENIORLIFE
- Chain ID: 389
- Provider Changed Ownership in Last 12 Months: N
- With a Resident and Family Council: Both
- Automatic Sprinkler Systems in All Required Areas: Yes
- Average Number of Residents per Day: 54.8
- Overall Rating: 4
- Health Inspection Rating: 3
- QM Rating: 5
- Long-Stay QM Rating: 5
- Short-Stay QM Rating: 5
Care Compare, October 1, 2026: provider information NH_ProviderInfo_Oct2026.csv · inspections NH_SurveySummary_Oct2026.csv · citations NH_HealthCitations_Oct2026.csv · ownership NH_Ownership_Oct2026.csv.
Nothing on file for OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN: no penalty in Care Compare.
Other nursing facilities in FRANKLIN and Ohio
- MOMENTOUS HEALTH AT FRANKLIN
- TRANQUILITY OF RICHMOND HEIGHTS RICHMOND HEIGHTS
- COVINGTON SKILLED NURSING & REHAB CENTER EAST PALESTINE
- ELIZA AT CHAGRIN FALLS CHAGRIN FALLS
- INDIANSPRING OF OAKLEY CINCINNATI
- CONCORD HEALTH & REHAB CTR WHEELERSBURG
- SAYBROOK LANDING ASHTABULA
- MCGREGOR AT OVERLOOK CLEVELAND
Report a figure on OTTERBEIN MIDDLETOWN’s record that differs from its CMS file, quoting 366376.