Skilled nursing facility · CMS certification number 155855

MCGIVNEY HEALTH CARE CENTER

CARMEL, Indiana · Medicare and Medicaid

Certified beds, as filed in Care Compare: 37

Finances, as filed

From this facility’s Medicare cost reports on form CMS-2540, each figure with the worksheet, line and column it was read from.

Cost report for 1 January 2024 to 31 December 2024 — a reporting period of 365 days, on form CMS-2540-10, settled, processed by CMS on 29 August 2025.

Revenue and expenses, fiscal year 2024
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total patient revenue	$3,897,819	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 100 column 100
Contractual allowances and discounts	−$242,609	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 200 column 100
Net patient revenue	$4,140,428	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 300 column 100
Total operating expenses	$4,140,667	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 400 column 100
Net income from service to patients	−$239	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 500 column 100
Total other income	$239	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 2500 column 100

Beds, days and discharges, fiscal year 2024
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total facility beds, all components	37	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 100
Bed days available, all components	13,542	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 200
Medicare (Title XVIII) patient days	117	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 400
Other-payer patient days	11,977	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 600
Total patient days, all components	12,094	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 700
Medicare discharges	2	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 900
Other-payer discharges	5	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1100
Total discharges, all components	7	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1200
Average length of stay, Medicare, in days	58.5	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1400
Average length of stay, all patients, in days	1,727.71	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1600

CMS report record 1436735, read from the public cost report file SNF10FY2024.zip.

Fiscal year 2023, ended 31 December 2023

Cost report for 1 January 2023 to 31 December 2023 — a reporting period of 364 days, on form CMS-2540-10, settled, processed by CMS on 23 September 2024.

Revenue and expenses, fiscal year 2023
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total patient revenue	$3,253,455	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 100 column 100
Contractual allowances and discounts	−$334,558	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 200 column 100
Net patient revenue	$3,588,013	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 300 column 100
Total operating expenses	$3,588,183	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 400 column 100
Net income from service to patients	−$170	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 500 column 100
Total other income	$170	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 2500 column 100

Beds, days and discharges, fiscal year 2023
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total facility beds, all components	37	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 100
Total patient days, all components	12,504	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 700
Total discharges, all components	5	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1200
Average length of stay, Medicare, in days	73	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1400
Average length of stay, all patients, in days	2,500.8	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1600

CMS report record 1395510, read from the public cost report file SNF10FY2023.zip.

Fiscal year 2022, ended 31 December 2022

Cost report for 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2022 — a reporting period of 364 days, on form CMS-2540-10, settled, processed by CMS on 31 July 2024.

Revenue and expenses, fiscal year 2022
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total patient revenue	$3,300,365	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 100 column 100
Contractual allowances and discounts	−$96,205	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 200 column 100
Net patient revenue	$3,396,570	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 300 column 100
Total operating expenses	$3,526,141	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 400 column 100
Net income from service to patients	−$129,571	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 500 column 100
Total other income	$129,571	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 2500 column 100

Beds, days and discharges, fiscal year 2022
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total facility beds, all components	37	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 100
Total patient days, all components	12,294	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 700
Total discharges, all components	17	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1200
Average length of stay, Medicare, in days	79.67	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1400
Average length of stay, all patients, in days	723.18	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1600

CMS report record 1390673, read from the public cost report file SNF10FY2022.zip.

Fiscal year 2021, ended 31 December 2021

Cost report for 1 January 2021 to 31 December 2021 — a reporting period of 364 days, on form CMS-2540-10, settled, processed by CMS on 20 December 2022.

Revenue and expenses, fiscal year 2021
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total patient revenue	$3,749,721	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 100 column 100
Contractual allowances and discounts	$239,391	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 200 column 100
Net patient revenue	$3,510,330	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 300 column 100
Total operating expenses	$3,510,481	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 400 column 100
Net income from service to patients	−$151	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 500 column 100
Total other income	$151	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 2500 column 100

Beds, days and discharges, fiscal year 2021
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total facility beds, all components	37	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 100
Total patient days, all components	12,268	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 700
Total discharges, all components	5	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1200
Average length of stay, all patients, in days	2,453.6	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1600

CMS report record 1338632, read from the public cost report file SNF10FY2021.zip.

Fiscal year 2020, ended 31 December 2020

Cost report for 1 January 2020 to 31 December 2020 — a reporting period of 365 days, on form CMS-2540-10, settled, processed by CMS on 25 November 2021.

Revenue and expenses, fiscal year 2020
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total patient revenue	$3,085,822	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 100 column 100
Contractual allowances and discounts	−$137,683	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 200 column 100
Net patient revenue	$3,223,505	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 300 column 100
Total operating expenses	$3,494,844	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 400 column 100
Net income from service to patients	−$271,339	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 500 column 100
Total other income	$271,339	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 2500 column 100

Beds, days and discharges, fiscal year 2020
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total facility beds, all components	37	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 100
Total patient days, all components	11,929	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 700
Total discharges, all components	19	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1200
Average length of stay, Medicare, in days	317	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1400
Average length of stay, all patients, in days	627.84	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1600

CMS report record 1305512, read from the public cost report file SNF10FY2020.zip.

Fiscal year 2019, ended 31 December 2019

Cost report for 1 January 2019 to 31 December 2019 — a reporting period of 364 days, on form CMS-2540-10, settled, processed by CMS on 17 December 2020.

Revenue and expenses, fiscal year 2019
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total patient revenue	$3,237,506	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 100 column 100
Contractual allowances and discounts	$119,756	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 200 column 100
Net patient revenue	$3,117,750	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 300 column 100
Total operating expenses	$3,117,834	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 400 column 100
Net income from service to patients	−$84	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 500 column 100
Total other income	$84	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 2500 column 100

Beds, days and discharges, fiscal year 2019
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total facility beds, all components	37	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 100
Total patient days, all components	12,459	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 700
Total discharges, all components	17	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1200
Average length of stay, Medicare, in days	186	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1400
Average length of stay, all patients, in days	732.88	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1600

CMS report record 1276544, read from the public cost report file SNF10FY2019.zip.

Fiscal year 2018, ended 31 December 2018

Cost report for 1 January 2018 to 31 December 2018 — a reporting period of 364 days, on form CMS-2540-10, settled, processed by CMS on 1 August 2019.

Revenue and expenses, fiscal year 2018
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total patient revenue	$3,450,975	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 100 column 100
Contractual allowances and discounts	$208,129	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 200 column 100
Net patient revenue	$3,242,846	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 300 column 100
Total operating expenses	$3,242,998	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 400 column 100
Net income from service to patients	−$152	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 500 column 100
Total other income	$152	CMS-2540-10 worksheet G300000 line 2500 column 100

Beds, days and discharges, fiscal year 2018
Figure	As filed	Where it comes from
Total facility beds, all components	37	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 100
Total patient days, all components	10,379	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 700
Total discharges, all components	21	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1200
Average length of stay, Medicare, in days	122	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1400
Average length of stay, all patients, in days	494.24	CMS-2540-10 worksheet S300001 line 800 column 1600

CMS report record 1239082, read from the public cost report file SNF10FY2018.zip.

Fiscal year 2017, ended 31 December 2017

Cost report for 16 August 2017 to 31 December 2017 — a reporting period of 137 days, not a full year, on form CMS-2540-10, settled, processed by CMS on 12 June 2018.

None of these figures is carried on this report.

CMS report record 1192610, read from the public cost report file SNF10FY2017.zip.

Nurse staffing

Nurse staffing hours from the Payroll-Based Journal, quarter by quarter, are on this facility’s staffing page, each quarter with the file it came from.

The staffing record →

Ownership, as filed with CMS

Care Compare

As filed in the CMS file dated 1 August 2026 (Care Compare ownership).

Owner or manager	Role	Type	Ownership percentage	Association
WITHAM MEMORIAL HOSPITAL	5% OR GREATER DIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST	Organization	100%	since 04/01/2015
BANKS, JOE	ADP OF THE SNF	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 12/08/2025
SHERA, RANDALL	ADP OF THE SNF	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 12/08/2025
BAYSTON, BRETT	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 01/01/2023
BRAND, JOHN	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 01/01/2015
CASTETTER, ANDREA	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 01/01/2023
COMPTON, JOHN	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 07/01/2015
FUNK, JAMES	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 07/01/2011
HAWKINS, CLAUDE	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 09/01/2013
HORNBECKER, MICHAEL	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 01/01/2024
PATRICK, LORI	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 07/01/2022
REAGAN, JULIE	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 02/21/2025
SCHMITS, FRED	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 07/01/2015
BRAVERMAN, KELLY	CORPORATE OFFICER	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 12/01/2021
EMMINGER, DEBORAH	CORPORATE OFFICER	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 07/01/2024
SELLERS, DANIEL	CORPORATE OFFICER	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 06/24/2024
BANKS, JOE	OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 06/27/2024
GIBAULT CARE, INC.	OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL	Organization	NOT APPLICABLE	since 04/01/2015
SHERA, RANDALL	OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL	Individual	NOT APPLICABLE	since 04/02/2018

Medicare enrollment

As filed in the CMS file dated 1 August 2026 (Medicare enrollment ownership), under the enrollment of WITHAM MEMORIAL HOSPITAL (enrollment ID O20170315001837).

Owner	Individual or organization	Role	Ownership percentage	Association date	Described in the filing as
WITHAM MEMORIAL HOSPITAL	Organization	5% OR GREATER DIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST	100	4/1/2015	Private equity company: No Real estate investment trust: No Holding company: No
JOE BANKS	Individual	ADP OF THE SNF	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	12/8/2025	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
RANDALL SHERA	Individual	ADP OF THE SNF	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	12/8/2025	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
ANDREA CASTETTER	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	1/1/2023	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
BRETT BAYSTON	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	1/1/2023	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
CLAUDE A HAWKINS	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	9/1/2013	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
FRED SCHMITS	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	7/1/2015	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
JAMES W FUNK	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	7/1/2011	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
JOHN COMPTON	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	7/1/2015	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
JOHN W BRAND	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	1/1/2015	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
JULIE REAGAN	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	2/21/2025	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
LORI PATRICK	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	7/1/2022	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
MICHAEL JASON HORNBECKER	Individual	CORPORATE DIRECTOR	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	1/1/2024	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
DANIEL E SELLERS	Individual	CORPORATE OFFICER	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	6/24/2024	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
DEBORAH EMMINGER	Individual	CORPORATE OFFICER	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	7/1/2024	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
KELLY BRAVERMAN	Individual	CORPORATE OFFICER	100	12/1/2021	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
GIBAULT CARE, INC.	Organization	OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL	100	4/1/2015	Private equity company: No Real estate investment trust: No Holding company: No
JOE BANKS	Individual	OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL	CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.	6/27/2024	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.
RANDALL SHERA	Individual	OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL	0	4/2/2018	Private equity company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Real estate investment trust: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle. Holding company: CMS paused the expanded ownership disclosure on Form CMS-855A in guidance dated December 11, 2025; this field has not been filed under the current cycle.

Changes in ownership

1 July 2026: KELLY BRAVERMAN no longer appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-07-01.csv
1 July 2026: JULIE REAGAN no longer appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-07-01.csv
1 July 2026: KELLY BRAVERMAN appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-07-01.csv
1 July 2026: JULIE REAGAN appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-07-01.csv
1 January 2026: GEORGE POGAS no longer appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: STEPHEN J BARDOCZI no longer appears as W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: LORI PATRICK appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JAMES W FUNK appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JOE BANKS appears as ADP OF THE SNF in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JOE BANKS appears as OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: DEBORAH EMMINGER appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JOHN COMPTON appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: FRED SCHMITS appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: DANIEL E SELLERS appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: RANDALL SHERA appears as ADP OF THE SNF in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JULIE REAGAN appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 February 2024: NANCY MORTON no longer appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: MARGARET MCFRYE no longer appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: BEVERLY NEWHART no longer appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: JACK JONES no longer appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: GIBAULT CARE, INC. appears as OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: BRETT BAYSTON appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: ANDREA CASTETTER appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: MICHAEL JASON HORNBECKER appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
15 March 2023: BRENDA ALFREY no longer appears as W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2023-03-15.csv
15 March 2023: RANDALL SHERA appears as OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2023-03-15.csv

Recent changes on this record

1 July 2026: KELLY BRAVERMAN no longer appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-07-01.csv
1 July 2026: JULIE REAGAN no longer appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-07-01.csv
1 July 2026: KELLY BRAVERMAN appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-07-01.csv
1 July 2026: JULIE REAGAN appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-07-01.csv
1 January 2026: GEORGE POGAS no longer appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: STEPHEN J BARDOCZI no longer appears as W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: LORI PATRICK appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JAMES W FUNK appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JOE BANKS appears as ADP OF THE SNF in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JOE BANKS appears as OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: DEBORAH EMMINGER appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JOHN COMPTON appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: FRED SCHMITS appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: DANIEL E SELLERS appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: RANDALL SHERA appears as ADP OF THE SNF in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
1 January 2026: JULIE REAGAN appears as CORPORATE DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2026-01-01.csv
29 August 2025: A cost report was filed for fiscal year 2024, on form CMS-2540-10. SNF10FY2024.zip
23 September 2024: A cost report was filed for fiscal year 2023, on form CMS-2540-10. SNF10FY2023.zip
31 July 2024: A cost report was filed for fiscal year 2022, on form CMS-2540-10. SNF10FY2022.zip
1 February 2024: NANCY MORTON no longer appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: MARGARET MCFRYE no longer appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: BEVERLY NEWHART no longer appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: JACK JONES no longer appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: GIBAULT CARE, INC. appears as OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: BRETT BAYSTON appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: ANDREA CASTETTER appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
1 February 2024: MICHAEL JASON HORNBECKER appears as DIRECTOR in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2024-02-01.csv
15 March 2023: BRENDA ALFREY no longer appears as W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2023-03-15.csv
15 March 2023: RANDALL SHERA appears as OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. Skilled_Nursing_Facility_All_Owners_:_2023-03-15.csv
20 December 2022: A cost report was filed for fiscal year 2021, on form CMS-2540-10. SNF10FY2021.zip
25 November 2021: A cost report was filed for fiscal year 2020, on form CMS-2540-10. SNF10FY2020.zip
17 December 2020: A cost report was filed for fiscal year 2019, on form CMS-2540-10. SNF10FY2019.zip
1 August 2019: A cost report was filed for fiscal year 2018, on form CMS-2540-10. SNF10FY2018.zip
12 June 2018: A cost report was filed for fiscal year 2017, on form CMS-2540-10. SNF10FY2017.zip

Inspections

Inspection cycle	Health inspection	Fire safety inspection	Health deficiencies	Fire safety deficiencies
1	26 August 2025	26 August 2025	13	4
2	2 October 2024	2 October 2024	5	7
3	22 September 2023	22 September 2023	25	6

From the Care Compare inspection summary file NH_SurveySummary_Aug2026.csv, processed on 1 August 2026.

Deficiencies cited

43 deficiencies on file, newest inspection first

Inspection date	Inspection type	Tag	Category	What was cited	Scope and severity	Complaint	Corrected	Correction date
26 August 2025	Health	F 0578	Resident Rights Deficiencies	Honor the resident's right to request, refuse, and/or discontinue treatment, to participate in or refuse to participate in experimental research, and to formulate an advance directive.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	15 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0605	Freedom from Abuse, Neglect, and Exploitation Deficiencies	Prevent the use of unnecessary psychotropic medications or use medications that may restrain a resident's ability to function.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	19 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0628	Resident Rights Deficiencies	Provide the required documentation or notification related to the resident's needs, appeal rights, or bed-hold policies.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	15 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0644	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	Coordinate assessments with the pre-admission screening and resident review program; and referring for services as needed.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	15 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0656	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	Develop and implement a complete care plan that meets all the resident's needs, with timetables and actions that can be measured.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	15 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0657	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	Develop the complete care plan within 7 days of the comprehensive assessment; and prepared, reviewed, and revised by a team of health professionals.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	15 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0684	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	Provide appropriate treatment and care according to orders, resident’s preferences and goals.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	16 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0690	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	Provide appropriate care for residents who are continent or incontinent of bowel/bladder, appropriate catheter care, and appropriate care to prevent urinary tract infections.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	16 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0695	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	Provide safe and appropriate respiratory care for a resident when needed.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	16 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0727	Nursing and Physician Services Deficiencies	Have a registered nurse on duty 8 hours a day; and select a registered nurse to be the director of nurses on a full time basis.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	15 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0812	Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies	Procure food from sources approved or considered satisfactory and store, prepare, distribute and serve food in accordance with professional standards.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	15 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0880	Infection Control Deficiencies	Provide and implement an infection prevention and control program.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	16 September 2025
26 August 2025	Health	F 0912	Environmental Deficiencies	Provide rooms that are at least 80 square feet per resident in multiple rooms and 100 square feet for single resident rooms.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has plan of correction	15 September 2025
2 October 2024	Health	F 0656	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	Develop and implement a complete care plan that meets all the resident's needs, with timetables and actions that can be measured.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	24 October 2024
2 October 2024	Health	F 0757	Pharmacy Service Deficiencies	Ensure each resident’s drug regimen must be free from unnecessary drugs.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	24 October 2024
2 October 2024	Health	F 0758	Pharmacy Service Deficiencies	Implement gradual dose reductions(GDR) and non-pharmacological interventions, unless contraindicated, prior to initiating or instead of continuing psychotropic medication; and PRN orders for psychotropic medications are only used when the medication is necessary and PRN use is limited.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	24 October 2024
2 October 2024	Health	F 0812	Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies	Procure food from sources approved or considered satisfactory and store, prepare, distribute and serve food in accordance with professional standards.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	24 October 2024
2 October 2024	Health	F 0912	Environmental Deficiencies	Provide rooms that are at least 80 square feet per resident in multiple rooms and 100 square feet for single resident rooms.	D	No	Waiver has been granted	24 October 2024
22 September 2023	Health	F 0580	Resident Rights Deficiencies	Immediately tell the resident, the resident's doctor, and a family member of situations (injury/decline/room, etc.) that affect the resident.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0609	Freedom from Abuse, Neglect, and Exploitation Deficiencies	Timely report suspected abuse, neglect, or theft and report the results of the investigation to proper authorities.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0641	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	Ensure each resident receives an accurate assessment.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0644	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	Coordinate assessments with the pre-admission screening and resident review program; and referring for services as needed.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0656	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	Develop and implement a complete care plan that meets all the resident's needs, with timetables and actions that can be measured.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0689	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	Ensure that a nursing home area is free from accident hazards and provides adequate supervision to prevent accidents.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0690	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	Provide appropriate care for residents who are continent or incontinent of bowel/bladder, appropriate catheter care, and appropriate care to prevent urinary tract infections.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0725	Nursing and Physician Services Deficiencies	Provide enough nursing staff every day to meet the needs of every resident; and have a licensed nurse in charge on each shift.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0727	Nursing and Physician Services Deficiencies	Have a registered nurse on duty 8 hours a day; and select a registered nurse to be the director of nurses on a full time basis.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0730	Nursing and Physician Services Deficiencies	Observe each nurse aide's job performance and give regular training.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0732	Nursing and Physician Services Deficiencies	Post nurse staffing information every day.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0760	Pharmacy Service Deficiencies	Ensure that residents are free from significant medication errors.	G	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0761	Pharmacy Service Deficiencies	Ensure drugs and biologicals used in the facility are labeled in accordance with currently accepted professional principles; and all drugs and biologicals must be stored in locked compartments, separately locked, compartments for controlled drugs.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0809	Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies	Ensure meals and snacks are served at times in accordance with resident’s needs, preferences, and requests. Suitable and nourishing alternative meals and snacks must be provided for residents who want to eat at non-traditional times or outside of scheduled meal times.	F	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0812	Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies	Procure food from sources approved or considered satisfactory and store, prepare, distribute and serve food in accordance with professional standards.	F	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0835	Administration Deficiencies	Administer the facility in a manner that enables it to use its resources effectively and efficiently.	E	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0842	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	Safeguard resident-identifiable information and/or maintain medical records on each resident that are in accordance with accepted professional standards.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0867	Administration Deficiencies	Set up an ongoing quality assessment and assurance group to review quality deficiencies and develop corrective plans of action.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0880	Infection Control Deficiencies	Provide and implement an infection prevention and control program.	E	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0881	Infection Control Deficiencies	Implement a program that monitors antibiotic use.	E	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0882	Infection Control Deficiencies	Designate a qualified infection preventionist to be responsible for the infection prevent and control program in the nursing home.	E	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0883	Infection Control Deficiencies	Develop and implement policies and procedures for flu and pneumonia vaccinations.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0887	Infection Control Deficiencies	Educate residents and staff on COVID-19 vaccination, offer the COVID-19 vaccine to eligible residents and staff after education, and properly document each resident and staff member's vaccination status.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023
22 September 2023	Health	F 0912	Environmental Deficiencies	Provide rooms that are at least 80 square feet per resident in multiple rooms and 100 square feet for single resident rooms.	D	No	Waiver has been granted
22 September 2023	Health	F 0921	Environmental Deficiencies	Make sure that the nursing home area is safe, easy to use, clean and comfortable for residents, staff and the public.	D	No	Deficient, Provider has date of correction	27 October 2023

From the Care Compare health citations file NH_HealthCitations_Aug2026.csv, processed on 1 August 2026.

Penalties

Penalty date	Type	Fine amount	Payment denial began	Payment denial, days	Fine ID
22 September 2023	Fine	$8,189			51076
22 September 2023	Payment Denial		20 October 2023	8

From the Care Compare penalties file NH_Penalties_Aug2026.csv, processed on 1 August 2026.

Care Compare provider information

Field	As filed
Provider Type	Medicare and Medicaid
Ownership Type	Non profit - Corporation
Legal Business Name	WITHAM MEMORIAL HOSPITAL
Date First Approved to Provide Medicare and Medicaid Services	2017-08-16
Provider Resides in Hospital	N
Continuing Care Retirement Community	N
Urban	Y
County/Parish	Hamilton
Telephone Number	3178460265
Provider Changed Ownership in Last 12 Months	N
With a Resident and Family Council	Resident
Automatic Sprinkler Systems in All Required Areas	Yes
Number of Certified Beds	37
Average Number of Residents per Day	34.1
Overall Rating	2
Health Inspection Rating	3
QM Rating	3
Long-Stay QM Rating	3
Processing Date	2026-08-01

From the Care Compare Provider Information file NH_ProviderInfo_Aug2026.csv, processed on 1 August 2026.

Get an email when this record changes

One email a day naming what moved on MCGIVNEY HEALTH CARE CENTER: the field, the value before, the value after, and the date of the file that first showed it.

The facility alert follows this one record: a cost report filed or a figure on one changed, an inspection, a deficiency or a penalty recorded, an owner added or removed. The certification number arrives filled in.

On 1 July 2026: KELLY BRAVERMAN no longer appears as CORPORATE OFFICER in the Medicare enrollment ownership file. That is one line of the alert.

What the alerts are, and what a day of them looks like, is on the alerts page.

See a sample

Following a list of facilities? The portfolio watch follows up to 100 certification numbers you name, on one subscription — on the alerts page.

The citable document for MCGIVNEY HEALTH CARE CENTER

This page shows the record as it stands today. The report is the citable document: the same figures with the cell each came from, and beyond this page — five facilities of a similar size in Indiana at the same fiscal year, listed by name; every change on the record rather than the recent ones below; the inspection and staffing history in blocks of their own; and a citation block naming every CMS file it was read from.

Read the citable document for this facility →

Every figure on this page is printed as it appears in the CMS file named beside it. A figure that does not match its file? Tell us on the corrections page, quoting certification number 155855.